Skip to main content

Free Banking Experiments

Free banking may be a neat theory, but is there any evidence that it would work in practice?  Are there historical examples of successful free banking systems? 

Before we answer these questions, we need to define what we mean by success.  We could use some or all of the following criteria: the absence of banking instability, a stable purchasing power of money, and efficient channelling of funds from savers to borrowers.  As the third criteria is difficult to evaluate, scholars typically focus on the first two.

We also have to define what we mean by free banking as there are some Austrians, such as Murray Rothbard, who argue that free banking means privately-issued bank currency should be backed 100% by gold, whereas others, such as Larry White, argue that banks in a free banking system can have a fractional reserve i.e., bank deposits do not have to hold £1 of gold in reserve for every £1 of deposits.  As historical examples of the former are extremely rare and belong to primitive financial systems, we are mainly concerned with the latter.  

There are many historical examples of free banking - Charlie Hickson and I provide a list of examples in our 2004 Cambridge Journal of Economics paper.  However, no historical examples of free banking are 100% pure as there are always some legal restrictions which 'pollute' the purity of the system. 

Most historical free banking systems were successful in that they delivered a money with stable purchasing power.  However, their success in terms of financial stability has been mixed.  

Probably the best known example of free banking is the banking system of Scotland prior to 1845.  This system was very stable, especially when compared to the English banking system - click here to see a recent paper of mine on this issue.

The most disastrous free banking experiment was in nineteenth-century Australia.  The Australian banking system experienced a huge crisis in 1893.  You can access my paper with Charlie Hickson on this crisis here.

Why were some free banking systems successful and others not?  My 2004 Cambridge Journal of Economics paper with Charlie Hickson suggests that the difference can be explained by the absence or presence of limited liability.  Free banking systems where banks were allowed to limit the liability of their shareholders were unstable, whereas those where shareholders had unlimited liability were stable.  

Popular posts from this blog

Bitcoin Bubble?

According to Robert Shiller , speaking at Davos, Bitcoin is a perfect example of a bubble - story here . Shiller sees Bitcoin as a backwards step in the evolution of money.   George Selgin , a free banker, takes an opposing view - click here .  Although he doesn't believe that Bitcoin is money, he sees its development as a fascinating turn in the evolution of money. In particular, he lauds the fact that Bitcoin production is constrained and cannot be infinite. There is a short video below where Bitcoin explain how it works.

How Valuable Are Connections?

Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, Amir Kermani, James Kwak and Todd Mitton have written a paper on whether firms connected to Timothy Geithner benefited from these connections. They do so by looking at how stocks of these firms reacted to the announcement that he was a nominee for Treasury Secretary in November 2008. They find that there were large abnormal returns for connected firms. Below is the paper's abstract and the full paper is available here . The announcement of Timothy Geithner as nominee for Treasury Secretary in November 2008 produced a cumulative abnormal return for financial firms with which he had a connection. This return was about 6% after the first full day of trading and about 12% after ten trading days. There were subsequently abnormal negative returns for connected firms when news broke that Geithner's confirmation might be derailed by tax issues. Excess returns for connected firms may reflect the perceived impact of relying on the advice of a small ne

Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles

Boom and Bust: A Global History of Financial Bubbles, co-authored with my colleague Will Quinn , is forthcoming in August. It is published by Cambridge University Press and is available for pre-order at Amazon , Barnes and Noble , Waterstones and Cambridge University Press .